Request an estimate
send us a message and a member of our team will reach out within 24 hours.
Inner Coupons
Request an estimate
send us a message and a member of our team will reach out within 24 hours.

Gas Furnace vs. Electric Furnace: Pros and Cons

HVAC technician using pressure gauges to inspect and service an outdoor air conditioning unit.

Your old furnace is on its last legs? You are faced with a replacement and can’t decide between gas and electric? And you would like to have the facts put in front of you without being steered to the most expensive alternative?

Homeowners in South Bend and the Michiana area put those questions to us at Bickel Heating & Cooling every heating season. With over a decade of HVAC experience under our belt, we do it all for residential and commercial properties: installation, repair and furnace replacement. Give us a ring at (574) 800-4559 to discuss it.

When it comes to picking a gas or an electric unit, it is a matter of what your home’s current setup is, the operating and upfront costs, and how cold the winter has been. In north central Indiana, the winters are no joke. We will go over both.

How Gas Furnaces Work

Natural gas is burned for heat in a gas furnace and a blower sends it through the ductwork. It is by far the most popular system in cold climates and there is a reason for that. When the mercury stays below freezing for days, the quick, abundant heat from gas is important.

The Case for Gas

For homeowners in our part of the country, gas furnaces have distinct merits:

  • Operating expenses are lower in most places as natural gas runs cheaper than electricity
  • The output is more powerful and puts out heat fast, which is good for an Indiana winter
  • The house gets comfortable in short order
  • A long history as the standard for cold-climate heating

The Drawbacks

They are not without their issues, however:

  • You will pay more for the equipment and to have it put in than with most electric models
  • A gas line is a must and not all homes are so equipped
  • Combustion byproducts mean venting has to be done right
  • They tend to have a shorter life span than an electric one
  • To be safe and efficient they call for routine maintenance and inspections

How Electric Furnaces Work

Here the heating elements do the work of warming the air before the blower moves it along the ducts. There is no combustion to speak of, much like a large, well made version of the coils in a space heater.

Why Go Electric

There are some advantages to be had:

  • The initial price tag is less than a comparable gas unit
  • If there is no gas line, installation is simpler
  • No need to vent since there are no combustion byproducts
  • On average they last longer than gas
  • They are quieter and do not require as much upkeep

Where They Fall Short

For some an electric furnace is not ideal:

  • Electricity is pricier per unit of heat so operating costs are higher
  • They are slower to warm up in an extreme cold spell
  • A hard winter can put a dent in the electric bill
  • In the coldest parts of Michiana they may not keep pace

Which Is the One for Your Home?

Unfortunately there is no one size fits all. It is up to your budget and whether you value immediate savings or long term operating cost.

If you have a gas line and want something to get you through a rough Indiana winter with efficiency, a gas furnace is usually the better value. An electric model makes sense if you don’t have gas service or want to hold down installation costs.

You do not have to make head of this by yourself. A competent HVAC contractor will take stock of your home, the ductwork, your energy use and your finances before offering a view. Have you had a quote from another outfit and it does not sit right? We give second opinions so the decision is an easy one.

We also provide free estimates and have financing to turn a big bill into smaller installments.

Bickel Heating & Cooling

Our team is on hand to see you make the right choice for your business or home, be it gas or electric. We are available around the clock in South Bend, Mishawaka, Bremen, Plymouth, Granger and the rest of the Michiana region.

Call (574) 800-4559 for an estimate and some plain spoken advice. We want to put you at ease and help you find a system that will see your home stay warm for years.

Call Us Today